The five services
Only two of these use AI on the phone today (Smith.ai and Posh). The other three are legal answering services staffed by people. They’re here because a lot of firms comparing AI receptionists end up deciding a person should take intake calls, and you should see both before you pick.
1 Top pick
Smith.ai
★★★★★★★★★★ 4.7 · 21 G2 reviews Best for: Solo and small firms that want AI to answer and screen every call, with live receptionists for the sensitive ones.
✓ Why it’s here
- AI plan is free for 25 calls a month ($3 per call after that), and Pro is $150/month for 75 calls at $2 each (vendor page, Oct 21, 2026)
- Listed in Clio’s app directory for both Clio Grow and Clio Manage. Call summaries and contact details sync, and new callers become new contacts
- Its human plans add law-firm extras per call: conflict checks ($0.50), accepting collect calls from incarcerated clients ($0.50) and taking payments through LawPay and others ($1) (vendor page)
- Live agent help is available as a per-call add-on on any AI plan (vendor page)
! Watch out
- Only 21 G2 reviews on the AI product itself. Its human Virtual Receptionists profile has more (4.9 across 72)
- Human-first plans start at $300/month for 30 calls ($11.50 per extra call), and most extras bill per call, so a busy intake line adds up
- The AI and human services are priced and set up separately. Make sure the demo you see is the plan you’re buying
If you want AI on the phone but can’t afford a botched intake call, start here.
2 Cheapest AI start
Posh
★★★★★★★★★★ 4.7 · 193 Trustpilot reviews Best for: Small firms with a light call load that want to mix AI and live answering in one plan.
✓ Why it’s here
- Lowest start here: $65/month with no minutes included, then $1.15 per AI minute or $2.30 per live minute (vendor page, Oct 21, 2026)
- Bundles let you split minutes between AI and people any way you like, from $130/month for 50 mixed minutes (vendor page)
- Trustpilot 4.7 across 193 reviews, and Lawyerist rates it 4.5/5 for law firms
- Answers in English and Spanish, does warm transfers and can return calls from your website intake forms (Lawyerist review)
! Watch out
- Not a legal-only service, so its receptionists answer for lots of industries
- Its AI plans only started June 1, 2026 (vendor page), so the reviews mostly reflect the human service
- Its integrations page names Clio Grow and Clio Manage, but it isn’t in Clio’s app directory and doesn’t say how the sync works. Test it before you rely on it
3 Legal-only, real people
LEX Reception
★★★★★★★★★★ 4.9 · 1,245 Trustpilot reviews Best for: Firms that want every caller to reach a trained legal receptionist, never a bot, with intake landing straight in Clio.
✓ Why it’s here
- Answers only for law firms, around the clock, in English and Spanish (vendor claim)
- Trustpilot 4.9 across 1,245 reviews, the biggest review base on this page
- A certified app in Clio’s directory for Clio Grow and Clio Manage. Contact details and intake notes map to the matter when the call ends (Clio listing)
- 30-day free trial with 150 minutes, and 30 short spam calls (under 30 seconds) free each month (vendor page)
! Watch out
- Not AI. LEX says a real person answers every call, so it’s here as the human benchmark
- Highest start price on this page, and minutes are rounded up (a 2-minute-28-second call counts as 3)
- The trial rolls into your chosen paid plan automatically when the minutes or days run out. Put a reminder on your calendar
4 Flat, all-in plans
Answering Legal
★★★★★★★★★★ 4.5 · 121 Trustpilot reviews Best for: Small firms that want US-based, legal-only receptionists on a month-to-month plan with every feature included.
✓ Why it’s here
- Answers only for lawyers, with US-based receptionists since 2013 (vendor claim)
- Every plan includes 24/7 answering, custom intake scripts, scheduling, bilingual receptionists and integrations, with no add-ons (vendor page)
- Published comparison price of $360/month for 100 minutes, a 14-day free trial, and no contract (vendor page)
! Watch out
- Review counts don’t match: Trustpilot shows 4.5 from 121 reviews, while its own homepage shows 4.94 “based on 800 reviews”
- Full pricing sits behind a form
- People answer the phones, not AI. Its Clio connection is listed for Clio Grow only, not Clio Manage
5 Best-known name
Ruby
★★★★★★★★★★ 4.5 · 853 Trustpilot reviews Best for: Firms that want a long-running, familiar receptionist service and mostly need messages taken and calls transferred.
✓ Why it’s here
- Around since 2003, with Trustpilot 4.5 across 853 reviews
- $250/month for 50 minutes or $395 for 100 minutes, no long-term contract (vendor page, Oct 21, 2026)
- Sends calls, messages and voicemails to Clio once you authorize it (Ruby help docs)
! Watch out
- Not legal-only, so intake is less specialized than LEX or Answering Legal
- G2 is lower: 3.7 from only 11 reviews
- People, not AI, and priced by receptionist minutes, so long intake calls cost more
What a law firm needs from it
A general AI receptionist answers questions and books appointments. A law firm needs a little more, and these are the things to check in every demo:
- A real intake script. Practice area, key dates, the opposing party, how they heard about you. It should collect facts, not judge the case.
- Conflict checks. The opposing party’s name should be checked against your client list before anyone books a consult.
- A hard stop on advice. “Do I have a case?” gets a polite handoff, every time. Test this yourself.
- Sync to your case software. Intake should land in Clio, MyCase or whatever you use, not in an email you retype.
- Nights, weekends and Spanish. People get arrested and hurt after hours. Check that it answers 24/7, and whether Spanish is included or an add-on (on Smith.ai’s human plans, a dedicated Spanish line is $1 per call).
- Urgent call rules. Decide who gets a live transfer (an arrest, a court date tomorrow) and who gets a callback.
Ethics and confidentiality
Callers often share sensitive details on the very first call. Before you put AI on your line, read the ABA’s first ethics guidance on AI tools (Formal Opinion 512, July 2024) and your state bar’s rules. In short, you’re expected to understand the tool, protect client confidences and supervise what it does.
- Ask where recordings go. Find out how long calls and transcripts are kept, who can see them, and whether they’re used to train AI models.
- Say it’s AI. Have it introduce itself as a virtual assistant, and say if calls are recorded. Recording-consent rules vary by state.
- Read the transcripts. For the first few weeks, skim every call. You’re responsible for what it tells people.
How to choose
- Count your calls and their length. Smith.ai bills per call. Posh, LEX, Answering Legal and Ruby bill by the minute. Long intake calls favor per-call pricing, and quick message-taking favors per-minute.
- Match it to your practice. Routine questions can go to AI. Upset callers in criminal, family or injury cases may be better served by a person, or by AI that hands off fast.
- Test the Clio sync. Run a fake intake call and check exactly what shows up in Clio, and where.
- Call it yourself. Ask for legal advice, give a fake opposing party, call at 2am. See what happens before your clients do.
Honest caveats
- Different review sites. Four ratings here come from Trustpilot, and Smith.ai’s comes from G2. They aren’t directly comparable.
- Review counts don’t always match. Answering Legal shows a much higher score and count on its own site than on Trustpilot. The Trustpilot figure is used here.
- Most legal reviews are of people, not AI. AI answering for law firms is new. Expect these products to change quickly.
- Prices move. Every price here was read off a vendor page on Oct 21, 2026. Check the live checkout before you sign up.
- Brand-new legal AI startups got cut. Plenty of them exist, but few have real review history yet. Same quality bar as every Steal This Agent comparison.
FAQ
Can an AI receptionist do legal intake?
Yes, for the first pass. It can collect the caller’s name, contact details, case type, key dates and the opposing party for a conflict check, then book a consult or send the details to you. It should never tell a caller whether they have a case or what to do. That’s legal advice, and it belongs with a lawyer.
Is it ethical for a law firm to use an AI receptionist?
Generally yes, if you supervise it. The ABA’s Formal Opinion 512 (July 2024) says lawyers using generative AI need to understand the tool, protect client confidences and supervise its work. Check your state bar’s guidance too, and have the AI say it’s a virtual assistant. This isn’t legal advice.
Which one works with Clio?
Smith.ai and LEX Reception are both listed in Clio’s app directory for Clio Grow and Clio Manage. Ruby connects to Clio once you authorize it. Answering Legal’s connection is for Clio Grow. Posh names Clio on its integrations page but doesn’t say how the sync works.
What’s the cheapest option for a solo attorney?
Smith.ai’s AI plan is free for 25 calls a month, then $3 a call (checked Oct 21, 2026). Posh starts at $65/month plus per-minute charges. If you want only people, Ruby starts at $250/month for 50 minutes, and Answering Legal lists $360 for 100 minutes. You could also build your own, covered on the main AI receptionist page.
Should callers talk to AI or a person?
It depends on your practice. A real estate or estate-planning firm with routine questions may be fine with AI first. For criminal defense, family law or personal injury, where callers are upset and every lead matters, a human or AI-plus-human service is the safer bet.
Are these affiliate links?
No. Every button goes to the service’s official site. If that changes, this page will say so.
Related: AI voice agent platforms if you’d rather build your own, the AI bookkeeper comparison, the AI sales agent comparison, AI employee jobs you can copy, or submit a job your AI teammate already runs.